Italy’s Constitutional Court is preparing for a pivotal decision that could reshape the future of citizenship recognition. On March 11, the Court will examine whether the so‑called Tajani Decree, now fully converted into law, complies with the principles of the Italian Constitution. The ruling is expected to have far‑reaching consequences, particularly for applicants pursuing citizenship jus sanguinis—the right to citizenship through Italian ancestry.
The case has drawn intense attention from legal experts, advocacy groups, and the global Italian diaspora. Many applicants had been waiting months or even years in consular queues or had already initiated their processes under previous rules.
The Court’s decision could determine whether these individuals continue under the new, more restrictive framework or regain the rights and procedures that existed before the decree was enacted.
A ruling that could reshape thousands of citizenship applications
At the center of the debate is the question of whether the Tajani Law violates constitutional protections by imposing new limits on citizenship recognition. If the Court finds the law unconstitutional, earlier rules may be reinstated.
This would directly affect people currently navigating the consular backlog, as well as those who had already begun their applications before the legislative change.
What the Court will examine
The Constitutional Court will evaluate whether the restrictions introduced by the Tajani Law infringe upon fundamental principles of the Italian Constitution.
The central issue is whether the government has the authority to impose administrative limits that effectively restrict a civil right recognized by higher-ranking laws.
The legal team challenging the law
The challenge to the Tajani Law is being led by a group of prominent jurists, including Benedetta Ballatore, Giovanni Bonato, Giovanni Caridi, Alfonso Celotto, Diego Corapi, Riccardo De Simone, and Monica Lis Restanio. Their collective expertise spans constitutional law, administrative law, and international legal frameworks.
This team argues that the law introduces restrictions that exceed the government’s administrative authority. According to their position, the decree—and the law that followed—interferes with rights that are protected by legislation of higher legal standing.
In their view, administrative norms cannot override or diminish civil rights guaranteed by the Constitution or by international treaties to which Italy is a signatory.
Take advantage of specialized assistance to secure your passport for a borderless future.
Core arguments against the Tajani Law
The legal challenge centers on several key arguments. First, the defense maintains that the law violates the principle of non‑retroactivity, because it imposes new limitations on individuals who had already begun their citizenship processes under previous rules.
This, they argue, creates an automatic and retroactive loss of rights that had already been acquired or were in the process of being exercised.
Second, the defense asserts that the law conflicts with Articles 2, 3, and 117 of the Italian Constitution.
- Article 2 protects fundamental human rights.
- Article 3 guarantees equality before the law and prohibits unjustified discrimination.
- Article 117 requires Italian legislation to comply with international obligations.
According to the jurists, the Tajani Law violates these constitutional protections by creating unequal treatment among applicants and by contradicting international agreements such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Treaty on European Union.
The defense argues that the law lacks the legal force necessary to suppress or restrict rights that were already consolidated under previous legislation.
In their view, the decree represents an administrative overreach that undermines the legal certainty and stability expected in a democratic system.
The government’s position
The Italian government, however, defends the Tajani Law as a necessary measure to manage the rapidly increasing number of citizenship requests. Officials argue that the system had become overwhelmed, leading to long delays, inconsistent procedures, and administrative strain on consulates worldwide.
From the government’s perspective, the new rules are intended to ensure that applicants maintain a genuine connection to Italy. They argue that citizenship should not be granted solely on the basis of distant ancestry without a meaningful cultural, linguistic, or social link to the country. The decree, they claim, is a way to preserve the integrity of Italian citizenship while improving the efficiency of the administrative process.
Government representatives also contend that the law does not violate constitutional principles, but rather clarifies and organizes the procedures for citizenship recognition in a way that reflects modern realities and administrative capacity.
A decision with international implications
The upcoming ruling carries significant implications not only for Italy but also for millions of people of Italian descent worldwide. Countries such as Brazil, Argentina, the United States, and Canada have large communities with Italian heritage, many of whom are pursuing or considering citizenship recognition.
If the Court rules against the Tajani Law, consulates may need to revert to previous procedures, potentially reopening pathways that had been restricted. If the law is upheld, applicants will need to continue navigating the new framework, which may involve additional requirements or longer processing times.
Legal experts emphasize that the decision will likely set a precedent for how Italy balances administrative efficiency with constitutional protections in matters of citizenship.
Ready to claim your Italian citizenship? At io.citizen, we provide a complete service to help you navigate every step of the process. From expert genealogical research and document analysis to certified translations and full support in judicial proceedings, our dedicated team ensures your journey is handled with professionalism and excellence.
Trusted by thousands and recognized by major global media outlets, we are the experts in bridging the gap between your heritage and your future. Click below to start your assessment and join our community of successful citizens.