Constitutional court of Italy examines limits on the right to citizenship

italian-citizenship-laws-history
The concept of Italian citizenship emerged with the unification of Italy in 1861. Before this, Italy was fragmented into multiple states, each with its own legal traditions and identity. The Law of March 17, 1861, proclaimed the Kingdom of Italy, laying the foundation for a unified national identity. However, formal citizenship laws were still undefined.
Decree-Law No. 36/2025 approved and the new rules for Italian citizenship: Photo of the Italian parlament
On May 20, 2025, the Chamber of Deputies approved Decree-Law No. 36/2025, now law No. 74 of May 23, 2025, with 137 votes in favor and 83 against, finalizing the proposal introduced in March by the coalition led by Giorgia Meloni, which was previously passed by the Senate on May 15.
From North to South - the best places to live in Italy: Photo of a church near the Dolomites, in the Italian alps
Italy is a country steeped in cultural heritage, boasting stunning landscapes and a deep historical legacy. Divided into regions, provinces, municipalities, and metropolitan cities, each area offers a distinct lifestyle and unique experiences. In this exploration, we’ll uncover the best places to live, considering factors like culture, economy, and quality of life.
Legal arguments for Italian citizenship by descent under decree-law 36/2025: Photo of man walking through a historical building in Italy
Decree-Law 36/2025 has significantly restricted Italian citizenship by descent, allowing recognition only for children and grandchildren of Italians, while excluding great-grandchildren and further descendants. This change has sparked legal and constitutional debates.
The role of Italy's regions in shaping national identity: Photo of an historical building in Rome
Italy is renowned for its rich regional diversity, which has deeply influenced its national identity throughout history. From distinct dialects and culinary traditions to varied economic models, each region has contributed uniquely to Italy’s character.
decree-law-citizenship-impact
On May 15, 2025, the Italian Senate approved Decree-Law No. 36/2025, a legislative measure that restricts the recognition of Italian citizenship by descent (jus sanguinis). The measure has sparked intense debate, with critics raising concerns about its constitutional validity, retroactive effects, and potential discrimination.
Constitutional court of Italy examines limits on the right to citizenship: photo of the town hall of Aostra, the Hôtel de Ville
Summary

In a landmark case poised to reshape the future of Italian citizenship by descent, Italy’s Constitutional Court convened on June 24 to assess whether the long-standing principle of jus sanguinis—citizenship through bloodline without generational limits—stands on solid constitutional ground.

The high-profile hearing, sparked by legal challenges and mounting public interest, could determine whether recent legislative efforts to restrict citizenship eligibility are upheld or overturned, with significant consequences for millions of Italian descendants worldwide.

Why was this session held?

The session was prompted by a constitutional question raised by the Bologna Tribunal regarding the validity of Article 1 of Law No. 91/1992, which permits the transmission of citizenship by jus sanguinis (right of blood) with no generational limit.

This marked the first time the Court examined the constitutional validity of granting citizenship purely through ancestry, even in cases where the individual has no direct connection to Italy. The plenary session, filled with legal professionals, students, and journalists, underscored the widespread public interest of the debate.

Begin your journey to Italian citizenship

Take advantage of specialized assistance to secure your passport for a borderless future.

The quote is quick, free, and without any commitment. We'll get back to you with more details within 24 hours.

What happened during the hearing?

Judge Emanuela Navarretta opened the proceedings with a technical overview of the legal questions raised, followed by oral arguments from several distinguished attorneys, including Marco Mellone, who spoke first and represented four separate appeals.

His defense combined historical perspective with emotional emphasis, affirming that jus sanguinis has been a cornerstone of Italian law for over a century and recognized by the Court of Cassation as a birthright that cannot be revoked.

He and others stressed that administrative inefficiencies—rather than the principle itself—were to blame for delays and complications in citizenship recognition abroad.

Another important attorney, Antonio Cattaneo, argued that the Italian Constitution does not impose generational or residency requirements on descendants seeking citizenship.

He criticized the new law for introducing discriminatory standards that undermine citizens’ trust in legal continuity. In his view, the legislation breaches the principle of non-retroactivity and violates Article 3 of the Constitution, which upholds equal treatment under the law.

What comes next?

Although the hearing did not focus exclusively on the new legislation passed by the Giorgia Meloni government — Decree-Law No. 36/2025 — the Court’s decision could influence the direction of citizenship law. After all, the case touches on the legal foundation that underpins many citizenship recognition claims.

If the Court finds that unrestricted jus sanguinis is unconstitutional, the new law that limits citizenship to children and grandchildren of Italians may gain further legitimacy. Conversely, if the previous model is upheld, the new criteria could face judicial challenges.

The judgment is highly anticipated, especially among the millions of Italian descendants around the world—particularly in the United States of America, where approximately 17.8 million Americans identify as having Italian ancestry — according to a recent United Census Bureau estimate — and thousands await clarity to proceed with their applications.

As of now, the decision has not been published and may take up to three months for official release.

In parallel, other judicial initiatives are underway. This week, for example, the Turin Tribunal accepted a request filed by AGIS (Associazione Giuristi Iure Sanguinis) and AUCI (Avvocati Uniti per la Cittadinanza Italiana) challenging the constitutionality of the new law. The request was submitted after the law came into effect, and the presiding judge forwarded it to the Constitutional Court for review.

Stay tuned to our channels for further updates.

Begin your journey to Italian citizenship

Take advantage of specialized assistance to secure your passport for a borderless future.