Legal arguments for Italian citizenship by descent under decree-law 36/2025

How Italy’s supreme court challenges government authority: photo of Castel Sant'Angelo in Rome
Two key developments this past week signal a powerful, unambiguous message: the courts are keeping a close watch on legislation that could infringe fundamental rights. The most emblematic example is the challenge posed by the Cassazione—Italy’s Supreme Court—against the government’s Decreto Sicurezza (Security Decree).
Constitutional court of Italy examines limits on the right to citizenship: photo of the town hall of Aostra, the Hôtel de Ville
In a landmark case poised to reshape the future of Italian citizenship by descent, Italy’s Constitutional Court convened on June 24 to assess whether the long-standing principle of jus sanguinis—citizenship through bloodline without generational limits—stands on solid constitutional ground.
The role of the italian diaspora in global italian identity: Photo of a small city in Tuscany
The Italian diaspora refers to the vast movement of Italians to different parts of the world, particularly during the 19th and 20th centuries. Millions of Italians left their homeland, seeking economic opportunities, escaping political turmoil, or following family networks abroad.
italian-citizenship-laws-history
The concept of Italian citizenship emerged with the unification of Italy in 1861. Before this, Italy was fragmented into multiple states, each with its own legal traditions and identity. The Law of March 17, 1861, proclaimed the Kingdom of Italy, laying the foundation for a unified national identity. However, formal citizenship laws were still undefined.
Decree-Law No. 36/2025 approved and the new rules for Italian citizenship: Photo of the Italian parlament
On May 20, 2025, the Chamber of Deputies approved Decree-Law No. 36/2025, now law No. 74 of May 23, 2025, with 137 votes in favor and 83 against, finalizing the proposal introduced in March by the coalition led by Giorgia Meloni, which was previously passed by the Senate on May 15.
From North to South - the best places to live in Italy: Photo of a church near the Dolomites, in the Italian alps
Italy is a country steeped in cultural heritage, boasting stunning landscapes and a deep historical legacy. Divided into regions, provinces, municipalities, and metropolitan cities, each area offers a distinct lifestyle and unique experiences. In this exploration, we’ll uncover the best places to live, considering factors like culture, economy, and quality of life.
Legal arguments for Italian citizenship by descent under decree-law 36/2025: Photo of man walking through a historical building in Italy
Summary

The recent approval of Decree-Law 36/2025 – now law No. 74 of May 23, 2025 – has significantly altered the rules for acquiring Italian citizenship by descent (jus sanguinis). 

Previously, citizenship recognition had no generational limits, allowing descendants of Italians—regardless of how many generations removed from their Italian ancestor—to apply for nationality. However, the new law restricts citizenship recognition only to children and grandchildren of Italians, excluding great-grandchildren and further descendants.

This shift has sparked legal and constitutional debates, with critics arguing that the decree violates fundamental rights under Italian and European law. Multiple legal challenges are expected in the coming years, based on key arguments that seek to invalidate or amend the decree’s provisions.

This article examines the main constitutional and international law arguments that are likely to be used when applying for citizenship under the new framework.

Violation of the principle of equality, breach of proportionality standards, and retroactive actions

Law No. 74 of May 23, 2025 introduces retroactive restrictions on Italian citizenship, contradicting established legal principles that laws should only govern future events. This approach raises constitutional concerns, as previous Constitutional Court rulings have declared such retroactive measures unconstitutional when they lack safeguards for reasonableness and legitimate expectation.

Furthermore, the decree disregards long-standing citizenship rules, such as the principle that nationality should be regulated by the law in force at the time of the event.

The Italian Supreme Court (SS.UU. 4466/2009 and 4467/2009) has affirmed that jus sanguinis citizenship is declarative, meaning individuals inherit nationality at birth and are entitled to recognition rather than needing to acquire it through administrative conditions.

Additionally, the decree imposes gender-based restrictions, violating Article 3 of the Italian Constitution, which prohibits discrimination based on sex or birth status. The cutoff date for maternal-line claims creates unequal treatment, favoring descendants of Italian fathers while excluding those tracing lineage through their mother. Past Supreme Court rulings have reaffirmed equal citizenship transmission rights, making this restriction legally indefensible.

Begin your journey to Italian citizenship

Take advantage of specialized assistance to secure your passport for a borderless future.

The quote is quick, free, and without any commitment. We'll get back to you with more details within 24 hours.

Furthermore, Decree-Law 36/2025 establishes retroactive deadlines, stating that individuals who fail to complete their citizenship application by March 27, 2025, will lose their right to recognition, even if they were previously eligible. Article 25 of the Italian Constitution prohibits retroactive laws that negatively impact already acquired rights, and the Italian Constitutional Court (Sent. No. 4/2024) has ruled that any retroactive limitation must be proportionate and reasonable.

Beyond domestic concerns, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has ruled against retroactive citizenship restrictions in cases like Genovese vs. Malta (2011), affirming that states cannot arbitrarily strip individuals of nationality without legitimate justification. By retroactively voiding valid claims, Decree-Law 36/2025 may violate both Italian and international legal standards, providing affected individuals with strong grounds to contest its enforcement.

Potential judicial challenges and legal strategies

With so many constitutional and international law violations, there are two legal avenues available for challenging citizenship denials under Decree-Law 36/2025:

  • Appeals to the Italian Constitutional Court: Applicants can challenge the law’s constitutional validity through lower court referrals.
     
  • European Court of Human Rights: A case could be brought under Articles 6, 8, and 14 of the CEDU, citing gender discrimination and arbitrary nationality restrictions.

The future of Italian citizenship by descent

The restrictive measures introduced by Decree-Law 36/2025 mark a significant shift in Italian citizenship law, limiting access to nationality for millions of descendants worldwide.

Applicants affected by the decree should prepare legal arguments based on established jurisprudence, leveraging Italian and international human rights protections. If judicial challenges succeed, future amendments or rulings could restore citizenship rights, reinforcing the principles of equality and legal consistency within Italy’s nationality laws.

Begin your journey to Italian citizenship

Take advantage of specialized assistance to secure your passport for a borderless future.